Cooking Sugar

sugar syrup
Many cooks stay away from candy making because they are worried about crystallization, an event that can ruin a batch of sugar within minutes. If you understand a little about the process, it’s not that hard.

Sugar starts out in crystalline form. Once liquefied the two single sugar molecules, glucose and fructose, separate. During cooking they naturally try to rejoin with each other. If a stray crystal, or a speck of anything foreign, enters the pot, the molecules will gravitate towards it, grab hold, and start forming a gigantic crystal. (It’s the phenomenon demonstrated when you made rock candy in third grade science class.)

To prevent those pesky molecules from taking over, recipes contain extra glucose (in the form of corn syrup) or acid. These ingredients discourage the re-forming of crystals. There are also some precautions you can take while the sugar is cooking. Never stir a pot of sugar unless a recipe tells you to. (It may if there are other ingredients in the pot, like butter). The agitation will bring any foreign particles into play. If crystals begin to accumulate on the side of the pan as the sugar cooks, they can be dissolved and wiped away with a moist, clean pastry brush. Be careful not to simply wash the crystals down into the pot.

The best defense against crystallization is to simply use a clean pan, clean sugar, and wipe the sides of the pot clean of any stray grains of sugar before the pot hits the heat. Set the pot over high heat and do not touch it until it is done. The more you wiggle, stir, shake, and jostle the syrup, the closer to the edge of crystallization you push it.

When cooking sugar on top of the stove a candy thermometer makes the task super simple, provided that the thermometer is accurate. The old-fashioned method of testing sugar stages with ice water is easy too, and in most cases more reliable. Have a bowl of ice at the ready as the sugar cooks. As the bubbles get larger and the mixture starts to thicken, spoon out a small amount into the ice water. Immediately feel its consistency. If the recipe calls for soft-ball sugar, you should easily be able to form the sugar into a ball. Hard-ball sugar will keep the ball shape once formed. Crack stage will harden immediately once it hits the water, and will crack easily. Hard crack will not stick in your teeth when you chew it.

Sugar boiled on its own will be clear until it reaches the hard-crack stage. There it begins turning amber as it hits caramel, and on to black as it starts to burn. If the recipe has other ingredients, like butter or milk, it will begin to darken sooner, and hard-crack will be rich caramel color.

One final note of caution: It’s hot! Be careful, pay attention, and don’t screw around near the stove. The worst kitchen injuries of my past all revolve around sugar and stupid behavior.

Print this technique

click on a technique below

Frozen Fruit

Frozen Puff Pastry

Cleaning Chicken Livers

SALT OF THE EARTH A brief guide to the rainbow spectrum of salts around the world

A Quick Primer on Buying and Using Fancy Salt

Sriracha Salt

Ash Infused Salt

Beef Cuts: Brisket

Stock: The Foundation of Cuisine

Whole Spices

Yeast Bread Techniques

Using Cardamom


Top 5 Thanksgiving Tips

The Crimped Edge

The Black-Eyed Pea

Super Sprouts

Sundried Tomatoes

Simple Syrup

Sesame Seeds


Scoville Units




Pie Dough

Peeling and Chopping Apples

Pearl Onions

Parts of the Knife and Knife Care



Pan Preparation

Nut Flowers

Muffin Tins

Mise en Place

Melting Chocolate

Making Cheese


Instant-Read Thermometers

Homemade Jam

Ground Spices and Spice Blends

Pâte à Choux

Food Mills and Ricers

Filling Cream Puffs


Easy Oven Bacon


Deep Frying

Day Old Bread

Crème Fraiche

Crème Anglaise

Cooling and Drying

Cooking Sugar


Citrus Supremes

Cinnamon Sugar

Chile Paste and Powder

Chicken Fabrication (a/k/a Butchering)

Carving Whole Roasted Birds




Buying Chicken

Buerre Noisette

Blind Baking

Beans, Beans, the Magical Fruit






Adding Alternatively

Ice Cream Machines

Espresso Granita

Knife Skills



Ice Bath


Egg Wash

The Creaming Method


Chopping Chocolate

The Tonka Bean

Simmering vs. Boiling

Whole Grains

Pounding and Tenderizing Meat

Chile Guide

Cooking Pasta


The Cut-in Technique


Peeling and Seeding Cucumbers

Frying Fish

Maceration and Infusion


Vanilla Beans

Ice Cream Freezers

Buerre Noisette



Seasoning Cast Iron

Toasting Nuts

Grating Nutmeg


Internal Temperatures for Beef

Whipping Cream

Egg Wash


Adding Alternately

A Berry Primer